
"Peter. What a surprise."
Peter walks closer to Sylar and holds his hand behind his back, gripping a small box tightly.
Sylar notices that his hand is hidden and grins. "Whatcha got there, Pete?"
He takes his hand out and reveals the box. "So I can tell on you," he admits.
Sylar raises his eyebrows and laughs. "Why are you being so honest? You're making this too easy."
Peter smiles and his eyes focus on the men standing behind Sylar, holding guns. Sylar's smile slowly fades and he turns around just a few seconds too late. The men all shoot him at once, each tranquilizer piercing him right in the neck and back. Sylar turns back to Peter and falls to the ground.
The men pick Sylar up and move him to a truck where they tie him up and shove a tube up his nose, which keeps him unconscious. Peter meets up with Noah and Mohinder back at the building where they're being held.
"Nicely done, Petrelli," Noah says after placing his hand on his shoulder.
Peter doesn't smile back, but looks guilty for what he's done.
"Is something wrong, Peter?" Mohinder asks nicely.
He shakes his head, still frowning. "I feel wrong... keeping them away from each other."
Noah laughs condescendingly, and looks at Peter. "You feel bad for a supervillain and an immature little girl? You did your job. Now go home."
Mohinder looks sadly at Noah. "Should I go, too? Am I of no use to you?"
"No, Mohinder. We could use you here. You're a good doctor." He nods at Mohinder and walks away.
"Geneticist." He says under his breath.
Noah goes to Sylar's cell and laughs when he sees him asleep and belted down. "What a relief..." he says to himself. "Now to torture that little crybaby."
He walks back to Elle's cell and turns all the lights on, shocking her. She stands up and frowns at Noah.
"Guess who we found?" he teases.
Elle gasps. "No! What did you do to him?!" she yells.
Noah laughs. "Oh, he's just haevily sedated and strapped down to a metal table. He won't be
leaving anytime soon."
She walks up to the window and slams it. "Noah, let us go! Let us GO!" she demands.
Noah smiles and walks away, hitting the light switch on his way out. Elle screams for him and zaps the window furiously. She continues using her ability until she's worn out, and she sits back down. She looks back at the metal table and grunts.
Peter, still nearby, stands sadly under an awning. He looks back towards the building and frowns. "Why do I have to be so good?" he whispers to himself. Claire Bennet walks around the corner and smiles.
"Peter?" she grins.
He turns around and smiles. "Claire." He laughs and hugs her tightly. "What're you doing here?"
She laughs. "My dad... My... Noah," she mumbles. "He told me to meet him near here. Do you have any idea what he's doing in Jersey?"
Peter shakes his head. "I... I can't..." he stops himself. "I don't know."
She frowns. "You can't what? Is something wrong?" She puts her hand on his arm.
"I did something bad, Claire. Well... sort of. I just feel awful about it."
She nods. "Me, too."
Peter raises his eyebrow and frowns. "What did you do?"
She laughs. "I... went to dinner with Elle Bishop. And... Sylar. I told them you were in New York."
Peter places his hand on Claire's shoulder and laughs. "Noah didn't tell you...?"
"Tell me what?"
"That was part of his plan to catch Sylar and Elle. That's what I feel bad about. I was in on it. And now they're apart-- separated."
Claire's face goes from confused to angry. "Plan? I was part of that plan? I helped my father do something as awful as separating two people... in love?"
"You didn't know, Claire," he says.
"I should've!" she yells. "I mean, I know I don't like them, but they're in love! And I pulled them apart!" She pauses for a moment. "What does he want with them?"
"He wants to do some testing on Elle, and doesn't want Sylar in his way," Peter explains.
"Testing? What kind of testing? Why does my dad want to do that?"
"Didn't you...? Elle's pregnant. He wants to see if the baby has-"
Claire interrupts, shocked. "She's pregnant? With Sylar's baby?"
Peter nods. "Yes. And Noah wants to know if it'll be born with abilities."
She covers her mouth. "That's AWFUL!"
"Claire... Do you want to help me..."
"I'm in."
He laughs. "I didn't ask you yet."
"I know you want to free them. So do I. Let's go." She takes Peter's hand and starts walking until she realizes she has no idea where they're going. She stops and looks at Peter. "Um, Pete, where are we going?"
He laughs and grabs her hand, walking briskly to the building. When they arrive, Claire gasps and looks up at the building.
"Pinehearst? This is where I took Elle to get her powers fixed... this is where Sylar worked!"
Peter smiles and takes Claire inside. They run into Noah on their way down the hall. Peter keeps walking and Claire stands with her dad.
"Clairebear?" he says, and turns around to look at Peter. Claire grabs his shoulder and spins him back aroung angrily.
"Dad! How could you?" she yells.
"What are you talking about Clairebe-"
"You're testing on Elle! You've got them separated! How could you do that to them?" she continues furiously.
As their conversation goes on in a very angry tone, Peter is searching for Sylar's cell. Mohinder walks into the hall and they slam into each other.
"Peter? What're you doing back here?"
"Sorry, Mohinder. No time to talk." He starts to walk away again, until Mohinder grabs his shoulder.
"Is there anything I can help you with?"
Peter nods. "Find me Sylar's cell."
Mohinder frowns. "Sylar? Why do you need to find him?"
"I can't tell you my plans at the moment, Mohinder. Just point me in the direction of his cell."
Mohinder signals Peter to follow him and starts walking towards his room. He stops at the window and flicks on the lights. "There he is..."
Peter looks at the key hanging around Mohinder's neck. "One more thing..."
Mohinder looks at him and smiles. "Sure."
"I need your key," Peter says.
Mohinder shakes his head. "I'm afraid I ca-"
Peter punches him in the nose, knocking him out. His eyes widen as Mohinder falls to the floor. "Sorry, Mo..." He rips the key off of his neck and unlocks the cell. He walks in and pulls the medicine tube out of Sylar's nose. Sylar, unable to move his arms and legs, opens his eyes and squints at Peter. "You," he growls.
"I'm trying to help you. And Elle." He starts unstrapping Sylar's arms when he sits up and grabs his neck.
"You brought me to this place. How can I trust you?"
Noah runs in with a gun and shoots at Sylar's forehead, but he stops the bullet in midair. He gives an evil grin and uses telekinesis to unstrap his legs. Still recovering, Sylar stumbles when he attempts to stand up. Peter catches him and holds up his hand to Noah.
"Don't," he demands.
Sylar looks up and uses Elle's power to send Noah flying across the hall. Claire runs in after her father lands and walks up to the still-drowsy Sylar. "I'm sorry about how I was before. I had no idea I was part of the plan."
Sylar smiles. "It's okay. We need to get to Elle before your daddy wakes up."
They walk down the hall, Sylar's arm wrapped around Peter's shoulder. Peter notices that Mohinder is gone and start walking faster. Suddenly, Mohinder walks out from behind a filing cabinet, holding a gun.
"I'll shoot... I will," he says shakily.
He aims at Sylar and drops the gun.
"You want to turn around and forget this ever happened," Sylar says, using Eden's persuasion ability.
Peter smiles and they keep walking after Mohinder walks into an office. They arrive at Elle's cell and Sylar picks himself up. He takes the key from Peter and runs in, and she jumps up to hug him. "I was so scared," she whispers.
Sylar kisses her and puts her back on the floor, taking her hand. They run out with Peter and Claire and hurry away from the building.
"Does anybody have a car?" Sylar asks.
"My dad's..." Claire responds.
Claire runs to the parking lot and breaks the car window, filling her hand with shards of glass. They all slide out and she unlocks it quickly. "Can anyone do that weird car-starting trick?"
Sylar runs over and gets in the driver seat, then leans under the steering. "I'm a watchmaker. I can fix anything," he jokes. Claire and Peter get in the back, and Elle hops in the passenger seat. Sylar gets the car started and they pull out quickly.
Meanwhile, Noah is knocked out on the floor, and Mohinder is doing work in the science lab.
"This is not something I ever imagined doing," Claire laughs. "I'm in a car with my uncle, the man who sawed my skull open, and the girl who tried to kill my father."